Salt of the Earth (1954)

Salt_Of_The_Earth_PosterThere are multiple methods of gaining insight and knowledge of one’s ethnic group. To obtain an accurate understanding of such, one can carefully examine another group’s cultural and ethnical demeanor/values for an extended period of study. As this may be efficient, the process is not easily obtainable where one is able to quickly put into practice. Televised media is another avenue for obtaining awareness of an ethnic group’s values and traditions, yet, it is not reliable as it may misinform its viewers and deliver a negative first impression. The film industry, specifically, portrays fictional and nonfictional accounts of history and historical figures. These displays may, however, may stigmatize a group or gender based on the actions performed in the storyline of a film. Furthermore, cinema creates a platform that addresses issues of gender-roles/inequality, conflict between the ethnic minority labor-class and their Anglo-superiors. The female characters of this film absorb the symptoms of inequality and yet transcend as they confront challenges when assuming multiple roles and responsibilities. Salt of the Earth is a film that presents these elements that exist among a mining community, substantially of Latina/o descent.

Salt of the Earth is a film about a mining community that issues a strike to address concerns of the occupational hazards that are accompanied with mining. However, conflict existed between other parties than that of the working members and company superiors/owners. The employees themselves were family men with wives that sought to be recognized as equals in the home just as the men towards their mining superiors. The women of the striking miners were not only in support of the strike, but also the backbone and bravado that the Latino men did not seem to possess enough of in order to achieve the goals of the labor-union. These examples are shown as the women react to the Taft-Hartley Act that prohibited men from continuing to protest against their employer malpractice, “…men are forced to end their picketing by a Taft-Hartley Act injunction the women take their place in the picket line…The women, indeed, come out looking stronger than the men, some marching with babes in their arms, resisting tear gas and making jail so unendurable for the sheriff that they are released” (Film.Society.Tripod). Additionally, women subdue and drive away authorities opposing the picket line. Alternately, the women’s involvement in the strike left the men to replace the household duties of the women. This left the men overwhelmed with the responsibilities that the women of the household seem to flawlessly and naturally perform. Character, Ramon Quintero, appears to be without a solution as his newborn baby is crying and daughter is asking to be fed. Moments later, his wife, Esperanza quickly resolves the infant’s crying with a bottle of milk. Another example of the incompetency of the Latino men in this film is observed when they lack the ability to come to a mutual agreement as well as one of the miners surrendering his loyalty to the company for his job security. Lastly, one can observe Esperanza’s broad awareness as she confronts Ramon about his employer’s disregard for employees and his lack of appreciation for his wife, “Why are you afraid to have me at your side? Do you still think you can have dignity only if I have none?…The Anglo bosses look down on you, and you hate them for it. ‘Stay in your place, you dirty Mexican’—that’s what they tell you. But why must you say to me, ‘Stay in your place.’ Do you feel better having someone lower than you?…Whose neck shall I stand on to make me feel superior? And what will I get out of it? I don’t want anything lower than I am. I’m low enough already. I want to rise. And push everything up with we as I go. …And if you can’t understand this you’re a fool—because you can’t win this strike without me: You can’t win anything without me!” (Ideology and Structure in Salt of the Earth).

The film, Salt of the Earth, depicts inequality between the working miners and the mine’s executive members. Specifically, the female figures of the film, were not only underappreciated, but were the solid foundation the men required to function about the work day and strike by up keeping the home, providing direction and feeding them while they marched in protest. The women of the film became the heroines, as the men were unable to go on about their labor force revolt. As for the lead protagonists, the character of Esperanza exhibited greater emotional intelligence, overall situational awareness, sensibility, resilience and capability than her male partner, Ramon. The Salt of the Earth significantly impacts the image of the Latino male as the women overtake and exceed the standards in both gender roles.

Salt of the Earth Reviews

Analyzing Salt of the Earth

Stereotypes Make For A Successful Series

Cultural and ethnic groups possess a profound system of history and traditional practices that determine its existence. These groups preserve their way of life by passing on the knowledge of cultural beliefs to young and developing generations. For an individual who is uninformed of a specific ethnic group, one gathers information on the subject matter through various sources. These sources can include historically documented text or mainstream media outlets such as news or film. Yet, one can adopt a limited perception of a specific ethnic group when absorbing the misinformation that is broadcasted through the bias lens of the Hollywood film industry. Additionally, the misinformation that is projected to mass viewers is prolonged through the support of the audience. Specifically, the Latina/o television viewers indulge as they may relate to the Hollywood infused image of the Latina/o community.

Jane the Virgin is a television series about a young woman, Jane, on a focused trajectory to be successful in a prospective teaching career and in love. Jane is raised and living with her grandmother and young single mother. As Jane is in a relationship, she intends on abstaining until she is married. Despite Jane’s dedication to sexual celibacy, she accidently becomes pregnant at a routine doctor visit as she is artificially inseminated by her physician. Characters of the television series are all somehow connected to Jane and her accidental pregnancy. The complex connection between characters and events occur in a telenovela (television novel) like format all the while displaying stereotypical behavior of Latina/o culture. The pilot show of the television series opens with a flashback of Jane’s catholic-rigid grandmother speaking to a child age Jane of the importance of Jane’s virginity. With her teenage mother lacking interest in the backdrop of this scene, Jane’s grandmother uses a flower to give a visual impression of the topic. She has Jane crumple a flower and asks to have the flower look as it did before having squeezed it in her hands per Jane’s grandmother’s request. After attempting this, Jane then tells her grandmother that she is unable to restore the flower to its original form to which the grandmother replies, “and that’s what happens when you lose your virginity, you can never go back.” The grandmother’s emphasis on Jane’s chastity may stem from her inability to prevent her own daughter from becoming the young single mother as depicted in the series. The episode then progresses thirteen years later into a much older Jane who is romantically involved, but manages to be an abstinent young woman. Following a superficially intimate encounter with her significant other, Jane joins her mother and grandmother in the living room to watch a telenovela, which Jane’s grandmother seems to indulge.

These examples of stereotypical Latina/o behavior along with the displays of religious implications, romance and dramatic love triangles/infidelity that unfolds throughout the episode is a misrepresentation of a culture that is fabricated by the Hollywood film industry. Additionally, the show’s success is owed to its telenovela like platform of multiple story lines involving numerous personalities and outcomes.
“They are a cultural touchstone, especially for Spanish speakers across the globe. Popular story arcs like long-lost family members resonate with Latinos whose families may have emigrated. Religious references will appear in several of these series, another touchstone to the predominantly Catholic Latino population.” (The Power of the Telenovela). As Jane the Virgin exhibits the Latina/o stereotype, its viewers endorse the television show’s interpretation of the Latina/o culture as its audiences seem to connect with the themes.

Reference links

Jane the Virgin Series

Latinos Love Telenovela

Introducing David

Hello professor and class,

I have been attending CSUDH for 2 years under the PACE program Interdisciplinary Studies. I love the courses as they contain practical knowledge and increase our awareness in the current generation of societal change and progression, or regression. Examining Latin portrayal through film with mindful critique will be fun and interesting. I am looking forward to learning with such an awesome group.

Follow me on twitter @davidsalin7

-David Michael Salinas